Post by Flowgli on Aug 30, 2019 21:42:35 GMT -5
Eight years ago, Doug Walker made a top 11 list of movies he said he would NEVER review as the Nostalgia Critic. Sometime later, he did reviews of some of the movies on that list as the Nostalgia Critic, so that list is considered outdated. A few of the things on the list are TV shows.
Here’s what he had put on the list:
11: Watership Down - Didn’t review it
10: A Goofy Movie - Reviewed it
9: Spider-Man (the Fox Kids animated show) - Briefly reviewed it in his video on Fox Kids
8: Attack Of The Killer Tomatoes! and Killer Klowns From Outer Space - Didn’t review them
7: Toys - Didn’t review it
6: Care Bears Nutcracker Suite - Reviewed it
5: Cats Don’t Dance - Reviewed it
4: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III - Didn’t review it
3: The Brave Little Toaster - Reviewed it
2: Anything Sonic-related - Reviewed Sonic The Hedgehog: The Movie (the 1999 English dub of the Sonic The Hedgehog OVA from 1996)
1: Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace - Did a top 11 list of good things in the Star Wars prequels
Now, keep in mind that only videos in the Nostalgia Critic series count when it comes to this list. Videos from other series like Disneycember don’t count.
So, with all that out of the way, I will now explain the purpose of this thread.
What we will be doing in this thread is say what movies we NEVER want Doug to make Nostalgia Critic videos on and why. And when you make your choices of movies and explanations as to why you don’t want him to review it as the Nostalgia Critic, make these explanations good enough; don’t make them weak or personal like “Because I watched it as a kid and I liked it”. None of that!
I have a couple in mind, and here’s what I got:
The Lion King (the 2019 remake)
Doug did NC videos on a handful of Disney remakes a year ago, and he did two videos on the original version of The Lion King, with the first one being a Disneycember video and the second one being an NC video. He also did a “Doug Reviews” video on the remake of The Lion King. From what I got of the remake of The Lion King, it’s a shot-for-shot remake with very little differences made to it from the original version. If Doug ends up doing an NC video on the remake, he’d probably end up mostly repeating what he said in those other videos he did on The Lion King. That’s why I don’t want him to do an NC video on the remake.
Anything Pokémon-related
In one of Doug’s earliest NC videos, he did one of Pokémon: The First Movie. He also said in that video and another video that he didn’t grow up with Pokémon. In just about every video in the NC series after the one he did on Pokémon: The First Movie, he kept showing how much he hates Pokémon to the point where his viewers, particularly Pokémon fans, just find the hate unbearable. Now, I know what he says in his videos as the Nostalgia Critic are not always his real thoughts, and that the Nostalgia Critic is actually a character in the series, but the way he talks about Pokémon and acts toward it in those videos can really get people very angry and annoyed. So, I don’t want him to review another Pokémon-related thing ever again.
That’s all I got for now. I may add more to this thread soon. But now, I’d like to see from you guys what movies you don’t ever want Doug to review as the Nostalgia Critic and why. What do you guys have to say?
Here’s what he had put on the list:
11: Watership Down - Didn’t review it
10: A Goofy Movie - Reviewed it
9: Spider-Man (the Fox Kids animated show) - Briefly reviewed it in his video on Fox Kids
8: Attack Of The Killer Tomatoes! and Killer Klowns From Outer Space - Didn’t review them
7: Toys - Didn’t review it
6: Care Bears Nutcracker Suite - Reviewed it
5: Cats Don’t Dance - Reviewed it
4: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III - Didn’t review it
3: The Brave Little Toaster - Reviewed it
2: Anything Sonic-related - Reviewed Sonic The Hedgehog: The Movie (the 1999 English dub of the Sonic The Hedgehog OVA from 1996)
1: Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace - Did a top 11 list of good things in the Star Wars prequels
Now, keep in mind that only videos in the Nostalgia Critic series count when it comes to this list. Videos from other series like Disneycember don’t count.
So, with all that out of the way, I will now explain the purpose of this thread.
What we will be doing in this thread is say what movies we NEVER want Doug to make Nostalgia Critic videos on and why. And when you make your choices of movies and explanations as to why you don’t want him to review it as the Nostalgia Critic, make these explanations good enough; don’t make them weak or personal like “Because I watched it as a kid and I liked it”. None of that!
I have a couple in mind, and here’s what I got:
The Lion King (the 2019 remake)
Doug did NC videos on a handful of Disney remakes a year ago, and he did two videos on the original version of The Lion King, with the first one being a Disneycember video and the second one being an NC video. He also did a “Doug Reviews” video on the remake of The Lion King. From what I got of the remake of The Lion King, it’s a shot-for-shot remake with very little differences made to it from the original version. If Doug ends up doing an NC video on the remake, he’d probably end up mostly repeating what he said in those other videos he did on The Lion King. That’s why I don’t want him to do an NC video on the remake.
Anything Pokémon-related
In one of Doug’s earliest NC videos, he did one of Pokémon: The First Movie. He also said in that video and another video that he didn’t grow up with Pokémon. In just about every video in the NC series after the one he did on Pokémon: The First Movie, he kept showing how much he hates Pokémon to the point where his viewers, particularly Pokémon fans, just find the hate unbearable. Now, I know what he says in his videos as the Nostalgia Critic are not always his real thoughts, and that the Nostalgia Critic is actually a character in the series, but the way he talks about Pokémon and acts toward it in those videos can really get people very angry and annoyed. So, I don’t want him to review another Pokémon-related thing ever again.
That’s all I got for now. I may add more to this thread soon. But now, I’d like to see from you guys what movies you don’t ever want Doug to review as the Nostalgia Critic and why. What do you guys have to say?